PDVSA cut its output goal by 9%, pushed back its target for that goal by 2 years, and expanded the amount of money it expects to ante up in order to fulfill the plan, according to a comparison of the company’s 2009 annual report with its 2008 edition.
Take a look at p. 43 of the report released Aug. 2 (my translation):
Review of Investment Plan and Principal Development Projects
Developing these business strategies, PDVSA estimates that its investment plan will require, in the 2010-2015 period, about $252 billion to reach a sustainable output of 4.46 million barrels a day (crude + natual gas liquids + ethane [sic – should be natural gas, most of which is methane]) by 2015. PDVSA expects to provide about 78% of the funds required for this plan ($197 billion), 15% from outside investors ($38 billion) and 7% from investments associated with the Socialist Orinoco Project ($18 billion).
That’s a change from the 2008 report, published June 2009 (my translation):
Review of Investment Plan and Principal Development Projects
Developing these businesses, PDVSA estimates that its business plan will require, in the entire 2008-13 period, about $139 million [sic – should be billion] to reach a sustainable output of 4.9 million barrels a day by 2013. PDVSA expects to provide about 75% of the funds needed for this plan, and 25% from outside investors.
That’s a lot of changes. The only thing they didn’t cut back on was the number of editing errors.
This is part of a trend. Back in the 2007 report (p. 35), they said (my translation):
Developing these business strategies, PDVSA estimates that its business plan will require, in the 2007-2012 period, about $78.116 billion to reach a sustainable output of 5.8 million barrels a day by 2012. PDVSA expects to provide about 75% of the funds needed for this plan, and 25% from outside investors.
Look ma, no major editing errors. Just a bit OPUD.
The good news is that PDVSA is starting to calibrate its goals with reality. The bad news is that the company has little cash flow to invest in these projects. If recent years are any indication, it may be able to come up with $15 billion a year, but that’s not even a third of what it needs. The rest, if it’s going to come, has to come from debt (or an IPO!).
Who is going to loan PDVSA $140 billion? And can this work out? Using optimistic assumptions — 5% annual GDP growth, no other new debt (!), and interest rates of 10% on new financing — this sort of borrowing would work out to the country having $287 billion in loans, the huge bulk being foreign debt. Venezuela would have to pay debt service at a rate of about $30 billion a year. In human terms, that’s almost $1,000 per capita leaving the country and enriching bankers and bondholders. In technical terms, it’s a debt-GDP ratio of 64%. I can see why the PDVSA bonds maturing in 2014 and 2015 yield almost 20%.
PS: Thanks to state newswire Agencia Venezolana de Noticias for covering the annual report 6 weeks late and leading on the new output number, which I had missed in my various prior perusals of this report. I bet some of you clever readers had already noticed this change, but from the Google I don’t see any evidence that it was covered at the time.